Two Food Writers Named Josh Talk Competitive Eating

  • Home
  • Food
  • Two Food Writers Named Josh Talk Competitive Eating
Giant Food

Why settle for normal sized food, or standard portions?

After Joey Chestnut took down 72 hot dogs at the annual Nathan’s Famous Hot Dog Eating Contest on July 4, I was once again reminded of the extreme gluttony of professional eating competitions. That day, ESPN sports business reporter Darren Rovell broke down the 10-time champ’s eye-popping intake, which included 20,160 calories and 1,296 fat grams. I took to Twitter to share my disbelief, and fellow L.A. food writer Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown had some interesting responses. I enjoyed the back and forth, and hopefully you do. Read our Twitter discussion, and let me know where you stand on eating competitions in Comments.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
Competitive eating is something I don’t understand, appreciate, or support. These “athletes” take years off their lives. For what?

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
They probably enjoy doing it a whole bunch.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
Probably, but to quote the James Cagney movie, “What Price Glory?”

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
I think its more self fulfillment than glory in the traditional sense. Enjoyment not from holding a trophy but challenging yourself everyday

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
Same could be said for football players, boxers, journos working 16 hour days. All take years off, everyone does it from some sense of love

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
You’re right, we’ve learned football and boxing are also self-destructive. That byproduct may ultimately tear down those sports.

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
Like I don’t think boxing should exist but I totally understand and respect the commitment of boxers.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
Sadly, many people who commit to sports like boxing and football participate to escape oppressive socioeconomic conditions. Not comp. eating

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
I’d actually be curious to see that data on comp eaters’ socioeconomic backgrounds. I honestly have no guesses.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
Potential rewards for even most famous competitive eaters are infinitesimal compared to potential rewards for boxers and football players.

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
For sure. But if you can eat real fast and you can’t run or punch good, you could see that as an opportunity. Money does play a role here.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
True. I appreciate your alternative perspectives, and you made me think about competitive eating in new ways, but I’m still not on board.

Josh Scherer‏ @CulinaryBroDown
Haha likewise man, good chatting. I have no intentions of A Clockwork Orangeing your eyes open to watch the gyoza eating championship.

Josh Lurie-Food GPS‏ @foodgps
If that’s the most horrific thing I have to witness, I’ll take the gyoza eating championship any day.

Tags:

Joshua Lurie

Joshua Lurie founded FoodGPS in 2005. Read about him here.

Blog Comments

Competitive eating truly is in a class of its own, but then again, our society seems to thrive on the bizarre. That being said, after putting down a few hot dogs ourselves for the 4th the thought of taking down 72 in rapid fire style is… intense to say the least. We’d love to see how a gyoza competition would go down. Consider us staying tuned…

Take My Shift Team, As much as I love gyoza (or any dumpling), the idea of eating them to the point of nausea doesn’t sound so appealing.

Leave a Comment